Bulletin 89-01: Failure of Westinghouse Steam Generator Tube Mechanical Plugs
. OMB No.: 3150-0011
NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION
OFFICE OF NUCLEAR REACTOR REGULATION
WASHINGTON, D.C. 20555
May 15, 1989
NRC BULLETIN NO. 89-01: FAILURE OF WESTINGHOUSE STEAM GENERATOR TUBE
All holders of operating licenses or construction permits for pressurized
water reactors (PWRs).
The purpose of this bulletin is to request that addressees determine whether
certain mechanical plugs supplied by Westinghouse are installed in their steam
generators and if so, that an action plan be implemented to ensure that these
plugs will continue to provide adequate assurance of reactor coolant system
(RCS) pressure boundary integrity under normal operating, transient, and pos-
tulated accident conditions. Thus, the actions are to ensure compliance with
General Design Criteria 14 and 31 of 10 CFR 50, Appendix A and the quality as-
surance requirements of 10 CFR 50, Appendix B. The actions requested by this
bulletin, with the exception of Action 2e, apply only to Westinghouse mechani-
cal plugs which have been fabricated from thermally treated Inconel 600, heat
numbers 3279, 3513, 3962, and 4523.
Description of Circumstances:
Numerous plants have experienced primary water stress corrosion cracking (PWSCC)
and leaks of Westinghouse mechanical plugs. On February 25, 1989, North Anna
Unit 1 experienced a mechanical plug failure following a reactor trip during a
feedwater isolation transient. The plug failure caused a 75-gallon-per-minute
(gpm) primary-to-secondary leak and was the subject of NRC Information Notice
No. 89-33, "Potential Failure of Westinghouse Steam Generator Tube Mechanical
Plugs." The failure mechanism involved a full circumferential severance of the
top portion of the plug from the body of the plug. The top portion of the plug
was propelled up the length of the affected tube by primary system pressure to
a point just above the u-bend tangent point where it impacted and punctured the
outer curvature of the tube. The top portion of the plug subsequently impacted
and dented an adjacent tube. The failed plug was installed in November 1985.
Westinghouse provided its preliminary assessment of the plug problem in meetings
with the NRC staff on March 23 and April 5, 1989. This assessment was docu-
mented in Revision 1 to Westinghouse reports WCAP-12244 (proprietary version)
. NRCB 89-01
May 15, 1989
Page 2 of 6
and WCAP-12245 (non-proprietary version), "Steam Generator Tube Plug Integrity
Summary Report," April 1989 (Reference 1). Westinghouse stated that the bulk
of problems to date, including the North Anna Unit 1 plug failure, involved
thermally treated Inconel 600 plugs fabricated from heats 3513 and 3962.
Westinghouse stated that material from these heats has been found to exhibit
only minimal (i.e., less than semi-continuous) intergranular carbide precipi-
tation which, in turn, Westinghouse attributes to a low mill annealing
temperature. Heat 3279 is a third heat exhibiting a similar microstructure
which was used to fabricate Westinghouse mechanical plugs. Westinghouse noted
that resistance to PWSCC has been shown to be related to the degree of inter-
granular carbide precipitation. The heats exhibiting only a minimal degree
of intergranular carbide precipitation (i.e., heats 3279, 3513, and 3962) are
referred to by Westinghouse as Category 1 heats.
Non-Category 1 heats are those characterized by Westinghouse as exhibiting
continuous or semi-continuous intergranular carbide precipitation. Based
on preliminary corrosion test results, Westinghouse had expected plugs
fabricated from non-Category 1 heats to exhibit significantly smaller PWSCC
corrosion rates than plugs fabricated from Category 1 heats. However, on
April 28, 1989, Westinghouse informed the NRC staff that certain plugs from
heat 4523 (a non-Category 1 heat exhibiting a semi-continuous carbide dis-
tribution in the grain boundaries) had been found to contain significant
circumferential cracking indicative of corrosion rates comparable to those
which have been observed for Category 1 heats.
At the staff's request, the Regulatory Response Group (RRG) of the Westinghouse
Owners Group (WOG) met with the NRC staff on April 5, 1989, to discuss the causes
of problems experienced to date with Westinghouse plugs, the potential safety
implications and consequences of plug failures, and the WOG recommendations for
ensuring plug integrity over both the near and long term. The WOG endorsed the
action plan developed by Westinghouse that was described during the April 5, 1989
meeting with the staff and which is documented in Section 4 of WCAP-12244, Revi-
sion 1. A summary description of the action plan has been incorporated into this
bulletin as Appendix I. The Appendix includes the NRC staff's understanding of
commitments made by Westinghouse to the utilities which have installed the
The actions requested by this bulletin are consistent with the Westinghouse
action plan described in Appendix I herein with the modifications as noted
in the Actions Requested. The indicated modifications reflect the following
staff conclusions regarding the Westinghouse action plan:
1. The need for remedial actions for plugs from Category 1 heats and from
heat 4523 should be determined on the basis of corrosion rate estimates
benchmarked against the field data from Millstone Unit 2 since this
represents the most conservative data of a limited data base.
. NRCB 89-01
May 15, 1989
Page 3 of 6
2. The absence of PWSCC on a sample of removed plug specimens does not
provide an adequate basis on which to defer remedial actions for plugs
where the acceptable lifetimes of the plugs do not extend to the next
scheduled refueling outage.
Remedial measures may be deferred (See Actions Requested, item 3) for plants
where the steam generator tubes are partially depth expanded within the tube-
sheet (i.e., length of tube expansion within the tubesheet is less than 3 inches).
Analyses by Westinghouse indicate that a tube which is partially depth expanded
precludes a failed plug from becoming a high energy missile within the tube.
Remedial measures may also be deferred (see Actions Requested, item 4) for
"sentinel related" Westinghouse mechanical plugs. This is justified on the
basis that tubes plugged with "sentinel related" plugs are filled with water.
This water precludes a broken plug from acting as a high energy missile inside
the tube. "Sentinel related" plugs are those which are either of the following:
"Sentinel" type Westinghouse mechanical plugs [Sentinel plugs are plugs
with a small diameter hole in the top of the plug which allows the
plugged tube to fill with water. The hole in the sentinel plug is
sized to limit leakage to less than the plant Technical Specification
limit for primary-to-secondary leakage assuming that the plugged tube
is completely severed.]
Non-"sentinel" type Westinghouse mechanical plugs which are installed in
tubes containing sentinel type plugs on the opposite leg of the tubes.
The actions requested by the bulletin, with the exception of Action 2e, are
limited to Westinghouse mechanical plugs supplied from Category 1 heats
(heats 3279, 3513, and 3962) and heat 4523. Additional actions pertaining
to Westinghouse mechanical plugs supplied from other heats may be requested
at a later time in a supplement to this bulletin, if found to be warranted.
In the meantime, addressees should give careful consideration to any future
Westinghouse recommendations which may be applicable to their plants con-
cerning plugs supplied from these other heats.
1. Addressees are requested to verify that information contained in References
1 and 2 relating specifically to their plants is correct for plugs supplied
from heat numbers 3279, 3513, 3962, and 4523. The specific information to
be verified is the number of Westinghouse mechanical plugs installed in the
hot and cold legs broken down by steam generator number, heat number, and
date of installation. If information from these references is incorrect,
appropriate corrections should be identified. Addressees are requested
to so state if their plants have not installed Westinghouse mechanical
plugs from the subject heats.
. NRCB 89-01
May 15, 1989
Page 4 of 6
2. Addressees are requested to take the following actions, to be implemented
initially during any refueling outage or extended outage (greater than
four weeks) which ends 30 days or more following receipt of this bulletin
and during all future refueling outages.
a) Steam generator tube plug lifetime for plugs from heats 3279, 3513,
3962, and 4523 should be estimated using the methodology from Refer-
ences 1 and 2 and should be based on the Millstone Unit 2 benchmark
subject to any corrections per item 1 above. Lifetime estimates in
Reference 2 for plugs fabricated from heat 4523 are based on the
Farley Unit 2 benchmark. These estimates should be adjusted to
reflect the Millstone Unit 2 benchmark using the methodology
described in Section 4.1.2 of Reference 1.
b) Addressees should implement appropriate remedial actions (i.e.,
repair and/or replacement) for all plugs whose estimated life-
times in 2a, above do not extend to the next refueling outage.
If operation is planned beyond a refueling outage that represents
the last outage before any plug exhausts the predicted lifetime,
an alternative schedule with the appropriate technical justifi-
cation should be submitted to the NRC at least 30 days before
the end of this refueling outage.
c) Prior to any plug repairs or replacement, addressees are reminded
that their responsibilities under ALARA require analysis of the
various plug repair or replacement methods available to deter-
mine which method will result in the lowest overall personnel
radiation exposure while still remaining cost-effective. In
choosing a plug repair or replacement method, the licensee
should consider the accessibility of the plugs and the dose
reduction benefit of using robotic manipulators. Prior to
plug repair or replacement, the licensee should consider steam
generator decontamination and/or local shielding to reduce
working area dose rates.
d) Installation of Westinghouse mechanical plugs from heats 3279, 3513,
3962, and 4523 should be discontinued.
e) Westinghouse mechanical plugs removed from steam generators, regard-
less of heat number, should be examined for PWSCC on a sample basis
for each heat. Addressees should maintain a record of these
examinations and the results should be provided to Westinghouse
to improve the database concerning the susceptibility of plugs
3. Remedial actions at plants where the steam generator tubes are partially-
depth-expanded within the tubesheet as described above may be deferred on
a one time basis to the next scheduled refueling outage if the outage that
immediately follows receipt of this bulletin ends before October 1, 1989.
. NRCB 89-01
May 15, 1989
Page 5 of 6
4. Remedial actions for "sentinel related" mechanical plugs described above
may be deferred on a one time basis to the next refueling outage if the
outage that immediately follows receipt of this bulletin ends before
October 1, 1989.
Addressees shall submit a letter within 30 days of receipt of this bulletin
1. The information under Actions Requested, item 1.
2. A commitment to Actions Requested, items 2, 3, and 4 or proposed
alternative actions with supporting justification.
The written reports required above shall be addressed to the U.S. Nuclear
Regulatory Commission, ATTN: Document Control Desk, Washington, D.C. 20555,
under oath or affirmation under the provisions of Section 182a, Atomic Energy
Act of 1954, as amended and 10 CFR 50.54(f). In addition, a copy shall be
submitted to the appropriate Regional Administrator.
This request is covered by Office of Management and Budget Clearance Number
3150-0011 which expires December 31, 1989. The estimated average burden hours
is 100 person-hours per licensee response, including assessment of the new
recommendations, searching data sources, gathering and analyzing the data,
and preparing the required letters. These estimated average burden hours
pertain only to these identified response-related matters and do not include
the time for actual implementation of the requested actions. Send comments
regarding this burden estimate or any other aspect of this collection of in-
formation, including suggestions for reducing this burden, to the Records and
Reports Management Branch, Division of Information Support Services, Office
of Information Resources Management, U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission,
Washington, D.C. 20555; and to the Paperwork Reduction Project (3150-0011),
Office of Management and Budget, Washington, D.C. 20503.
If you have any questions about this matter, please contact one of the
technical contacts listed below or the Regional Administrator of the
appropriate regional office.
1. Westinghouse reports WCAP-12244 (proprietary version) and WCAP-12245
(non-proprietary version), "Steam Generator Tube Plug Integrity Summary
Report," Revision 1, April 1989. NRC Accession Nos. 8904250229 and
. NRCB 89-01
May 15, 1989
Page 6 of 6
2. Westinghouse letter to NRC dated May 1, 1989 (NS-NRC-89-3432) "Steam
Generator Tube Plug Integrity Update." NRC Accession No. 8905040092
(Proprietary). Westinghouse has agreed to provide copies of this
letter to the affected utilities by May 17, 1989.
Charles E. Rossi, Director
Division of Operational Events Assessment
Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
Technical Contacts: Emmett Murphy, NRR
Keith Wichman, NRR
Attachment: List of Recently Issued NRC Bulletins
. Appendix I
May 15, 1989
Page 1 of 3
The following are the major elements of an action plan developed by Westinghouse
and applicable to all the mechanical steam generator tube plugs installed by them.
A. Westinghouse Short-Term Plan
1. Plants Currently in a Scheduled Refueling Outage
a. The need for immediate remedial actions should be determined on
the basis of planned effective full-power days (EFPD) until the
next refueling outage compared to the acceptable lifetime of the
plugs before they become potentially vulnerable to failure by
PWSCC. The acceptable lifetime is calculated using the Westing-
house corrosion rate algorithm described in Section 4.1.2 of
WCAP 12244, Revision 1. This algorithm was developed on the
basis of laboratory and field data and yields the acceptable
plug lifetime as a function of (1) the known degree of carbide
distribution in the grain boundaries for the heat from which the
plug was supplied and (2) the operating temperature of the plug.
Alternatively, the need for immediate remedial action can be as-
sessed by removing a statistically significant sample of plugs
and examining them for PWSCC. Remedial actions can be deferred
to at least the next refueling outage (see item B., "Westinghouse
Long Term Plan"), provided the removed plugs exhibit no signi-
b. Remedial actions, if necessary, should include
� Removing plugs and examining them to improve the data base
concerning the susceptibility of the plugs to PWSCC, and
� Implementing plug repairs*, and/or
� Removing and replacing plugs with mechanical plugs having
a preferred microstructure (i.e., non-Category 1). Before
the fall of 1989, the replacement plugs for installation
in hot legs will be supplied from thermally treated Inconel-
600 having a continuous grain boundary carbide distribution.
For installation in the cold legs where PWSCC corrosion rates
are significantly reduced compared to the hot legs, a semi-
continuous microstructure may be employed. Starting in the
fall of 1989, new and replacement mechanical plugs will be
made from thermally treated Inconel-690 which is expected
to further improve the PWSCC resistance of the plugs.
*Westinghouse and Babcock & Wilcox have developed plug repair techniques
involving insertion of a new plug into the original plug.
. Appendix I
May 15, 1989
Page 2 of 3
2. Plants in Operation
The need for remedial actions should be assessed and the remedial
actions implemented, as necessary, per item A.1. at the next scheduled
refueling outage. Westinghouse plans to monitor the performance of
each and every installed mechanical plug in service.
3. Areas for Additional Development by Westinghouse
a. Development of a robotic plug repair method to reduce radiation
exposure of workers.
4. Additional Testing and Analysis by Westinghouse
a. Analysis and tests to confirm that the rupture of an adjacent
tube is not a credible consequence of a plug failure.
b. Corrosion tests to refine the corrosion algorithm for plugs.
B. Westinghouse Long-Term Plan
Westinghouse will continue to monitor all Westinghouse mechanical plugs in
operating plants to support recommendations to utilities for implementing
remedial actions on a timely basis, where necessary.
WCAP-12244, Revision 1 (Reference 1), includes a listing of the following
information for each plant employing Westinghouse mechanical plugs fabricated
from Category 1 heats:
1. Number of Westinghouse mechanical plugs, classified as follows:
a. date of installation
b. heat number
c. steam generator number
d. whether hot leg or cold leg
2. Hot leg and cold leg temperature
3. Accumulated EFPD of each plug
4. Remaining lifetime of each plug as determined from the Westinghouse
corrosion rate algorithm
Note: WCAP-12244, Revision 1, provides three different lifetime estimates
for each plug based on three different corrosion rate benchmarks determined
from the field data. These benchmarks are the maximum corrosion rates
observed for plugs at Millstone Unit 2 supplied from heat 3513, for plugs
at North Anna Unit 1 supplied from heat 3962, and for plugs at North Anna
Unit 2 supplied from heat 3962. Westinghouse recommends that the lifetime
estimates for plugs supplied from heats 3513 and 3962 be based on the
. Appendix I
May 15, 1989
Page 3 of 3
Millstone Unit 2 and North Anna Unit 2 benchmarks, respectively, since
these are the most conservative benchmarks for the respective heats.
Westinghouse has made no specific recommendation concerning plugs
fabricated from heat 3279 since Westinghouse believes that all plugs
from this heat have been removed from service.
The above information will be expanded by Westinghouse in a quarterly
update report to include plugs from non-Category 1 heats. Westinghouse
will provide this information to the affected utilities, when it becomes
available. Westinghouse has already provided such information for heat
4523, including lifetime estimates.
Page Last Reviewed/Updated Friday, May 22, 2015