Part 21 Report - 2003-011-00
ENGINE SYSTEMS INC.
12205. Washington St. Rocky Mount, NC 27801 Telephone: 2521977-2720
P.O. Box 1928, Rocky Mount, NC 27802-1928
April 21, 2003
U.S. Nuclear Regulator Commission
Document Control Desk
Mail Stop OPI-17
Washington, DC 20555
Subject: 10CFR2I Reporting of Defects and Non-Compliance - Engine Systems, Inc. Report No. 1OCFR2I-0086, Rev. 0
Woodward EGM Controls
The enclosed report addresses a reportable notIfication about Woodward EGM controls.
A copy of the report has also been sent to our affected nuclear customers. Please sign below, acknowledging receipt of this report, and return a copy to the aftention of Document Control at the address above (or, fax to number 2521446-1134) within 10 working days after receipt.
Yours very truly,
ENGINE SYSTEMS, INC
Please let us know If ANY of your mailing Information changes - name of recipIent, name of companylfacility, address, etc. Mark the changes on this acknowledgment form and send to us by mall or FAX to the number above.
Quality Performance With Pride
(ESI) ENGINE SYSTEMS1 INC.
1220 S Washington St, Rocky Mount, NC 27801 Telephone: 252~77-2720
P0 Box 1928. Rocky Mount, NC 27802-1928 Fax: 252/446-1134
Report No. 1DCFR21-0O85
Rev. 0: 04/18/03
1OCFR21 REPORTING OF DEFECTS
COMPONENT: Woodward EGM Controls, PIN 9903-014.9903-016, 9903-188, 9903460
SYSTEM: Governor Controls
CONCLUSION: Reportable in acoordance with 1OCFR21.
Prepared By: Date:_______
Reviewed By: Date: ____________
Quality Assurance Manager
Quality Performance With Pride
Report No. IOCFR21-0086
Page: 1 of 2
Woodward EGM Controls, PIN 9903-014, 9903-016, 9903-188, 9903A60.
Engine Systems Inc. (ESI) has conduded an investigation of a condition reported with a Woodward EGM control. An EGM control, part number 9903A601 serial number 10019993 was sent to ESI for repair and refurbishment because of an instability problem. After repair/refurbishment, the site reported that the Stability and Amplifier Gain potentiometers were swapped. This condition could have been detected by verifying the control's actuator output signal (terminals 4&5) for a voltage range of at least +/-8 VDC. Woodward's functional test procedure for this part number EGM did not contain a requirement to verify the range of the actuator output signal and therefore the swapped potentiometers were not detected. The Woodward test procedures for all EGM (and the similarly designed EGA) controls supplied by ESI for nuclear service were reviewed for adequacy to detect the swapped potentiometer condition. The test procedures for the part number controls listed in the Component section above were determined to be inadequate. These EGM controls have been previously supplied or refurbished by ESl.
Test procedures for the part numbers listed below were determined to be adequate to detect a swapped potentiometer condition and therefore these part numbers are specifically excluded from thIs notification. The EGM and EGA controls listed below have been previously supplied or refurbished by ESI.
Part number Type Part number Type
9903-059 EGM 9903-003 EGA
9903-085 EGM 9903-037I EGA
9903-109 EGM 9903-225 EGA
EGM control, part number 9903460, serial number 10019993 was sent to ESI for refurbishment. D.C. Cook originally purchased the control new in September 1994. directly from Woodward Governor, and it had never been placed in service. When installed in November 2002, the control exhibited instability and thus it was sent to ESI for repair/refurbishment. ESI sent the control to Woodward Governor for the repair/refurbishment activity. Woodward performed a test upon receipt and the instability could not be identified; the control passed all testing requirements of Woodward's test procedure. Because of the age of the control, a standard refurbishment was performed; seven (7) capacitors and four (4) potentiometers were replaced. The control was successfully tested after refurbishment and ultimately returned to the site during the last week of January 2003. Upon inspection at the site, it was observed that the Stability and Amplifier Gain potentiometers were swapped. Another of the site's controls (same part number), with sequential serial number 10019992 was also inspected and found to have the same condition. Control serial number 10019993 was again returned to ESI to have the potentiometers corrected. The control was corrected and returned to the site in February 2003.
Both EGM controls were manufactured sequentially. Because s/n 1001992 was not refurbished, it is conduded that the potentiometers were incorrectly installed during original fabrication in 1994. When s/n 10019993 was refurbished, a like-for-like component replacement was performed and therefore the error was repeated.
Report No. 10CF~1~086
The EGM and EGA controls are used with tmcompensating" type actuators. For these systems, the actuator output signal is zero volts during steady state conditions and the signal's magnitude and polarity varies in response to load changes. Reversal of the Stability and Amplifier Gain potentiometers will limit the range of the actuator output signal and thus the dynamic response of the control would be limited. This could impact system response during load or speed variations. No other operability effects will occur.Controls that are installed and verified by load testing are therefore excluded from consideration of this reported condition.
ESI has searched its historical data and has determined the following customers have suspect EGM controls. Only controls supplied or refurbished by ESI are listed. There may be other part number EGM and EGA controls in service that were supplied by others, these will need to be evaluated as they are identified.
SITE PART NUMBER
American Electric D.C. Cook Nuclear Plant 9903-460
Energy Northwest Columbia Nuclear Plant 9903-016
Entergy Nuclear Vermont Yankee Nuclear Plant 9903-014, 9903-188
Entergy Nuclear Pilgrim Yankee Nuclear Plant 9903-014, 9903-188
Nebraska Public Power Cooper Nuclear Plant 9903-014
Southern Nuclear Farley Nuclear Plant 9903-188
1. ESI has added the requirement to verify the actuator output signal of all Woodward EGM and EGA controls for +1-8 VDC minimum range. This requirement is considered a critical characteristic for commerclal grade dedication of these controls.
2. Users should inspect all controls listed in the Component section that have not been placed in service or with operability not verified by load testing. This inspection can be performed by removing the contml's rear cover and inspecting for the following (reference Exhibit 1):
a. The Stability potentiometer, circuit designation RI, should be 150K ohms. b. The Amplifier Gain potentiometer, clrcuit designation R4, should be 25K ohms.
3. Any EGM and EGA controls with part numbers different from those presented in this document must also be evaluated for applicability of the condition reported. Contact ES l's Customer Service department with the part number and serial number of the control(s).
4. Controls identified as having revesed potentiometers should be sent to ESI for corestion. Contact ESI's Customer Service department for information about sending a control.
See pdf for exhibit 1
Page Last Reviewed/Updated Friday, January 31, 2020