Event Notification Report for May 18, 2008
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission
Operations Center
EVENT REPORTS FOR
05/17/2008 - 05/18/2008
EVENT NUMBERS
44223
Fuel Cycle Facility
Event Number: 44223
Facility: PADUCAH GASEOUS DIFFUSION PLANT
Region: 2 State: KY
Unit: [] [] []
RX Type: URANIUM ENRICHMENT FACILITY
Comments: 2 DEMOCRACY CENTER
6903 ROCKLEDGE DRIVE
BETHESDA, MD 20817 (301)564-3200
NRC Notified By: CALVIN PITTMAN
HQ OPS Officer: MARK ABRAMOVITZ
Region: 2 State: KY
Unit: [] [] []
RX Type: URANIUM ENRICHMENT FACILITY
Comments: 2 DEMOCRACY CENTER
6903 ROCKLEDGE DRIVE
BETHESDA, MD 20817 (301)564-3200
NRC Notified By: CALVIN PITTMAN
HQ OPS Officer: MARK ABRAMOVITZ
Notification Date: 05/19/2008
Notification Time: 17:20 [ET]
Event Date: 05/18/2008
Event Time: 17:21 [CDT]
Last Update Date: 05/19/2008
Notification Time: 17:20 [ET]
Event Date: 05/18/2008
Event Time: 17:21 [CDT]
Last Update Date: 05/19/2008
Emergency Class: NON EMERGENCY
10 CFR Section:
10 CFR Section:
Person (Organization):
MARVIN SYKES (R2)
BRITTAIN HILL (NMSS)
MARVIN SYKES (R2)
BRITTAIN HILL (NMSS)
VIOLATION OF A NUCLEAR CRITICALITY SAFETY APPROVAL - 24-HOUR REPORT
"At 1721 hours on 5-18-08 the Plant Shift Superintendent was notified that violation of a nuclear criticality safety approval (NCSA) had occurred.
"At 1720 hours on 5-17-08, the coolant system for [DELETED] was evacuated using an R-114 evacuation pump. The recirculating cooling water (RCW) condenser for that cell had not been disconnected or vented before evacuation of coolant system vapor or air, in violation of NCSA CAS-21 Rev. 01, 'Operation and Shutdown of the Diffusion Cascade,' Control 3.2.3. That control states: 'The RCW condenser shall be disconnected or vented before coolant vapor is evacuated.'
"This control minimizes the amount of water that is available to moderate fissile material that might be present in the UF6 region of the process gas cooler.
"Coolant system leak rate testing results were logged as of 2100 hours on 5-18-08 showing the coolant system to be evacuated to 30" vacuum and holding. At that pressure the system would be below the vapor pressure of water. Therefore, the coolant system being evacuated to that level and holding would indicate that no liquid water was present in the coolant system. The system being evacuated and holding proves that not only was the condenser free of any significant RCW to coolant leaks, but the process gas cooler was also essentially leak-tight.
"The NRC Senior Resident Inspector has been notified of this event. PGDP Problem Report No. ATRC-08-1471: PGDP Event Report No. PAD-2008-18; NRC Worksheet No. 44223
"This violation represents a significant breach of NCS administrative controls for this operation: however, the safety significance of the as-found condition was quite low. The worst case enrichment [DELETED] at this location was just above the minimum fissile enrichment, so that a very large mass of optimally moderated uranium (more than [DELETED]) would have been needed for a criticality to be possible. Moderation would have required excessive water intrusion into the coolant system through condenser tube leaks, and subsequent water intrusion into the process gas region of the cooler/converter through a concurrent process gas cooler lube leak. Even though NCS Control 3.2.3 was violated, no significant water intrusion occurred. Although the as-found condition of the coolant system did not contain water, the parameter is considered lost since the typical condition of condenser tubes would be expect to result in water intrusion and would not represent a reliable barrier to in-leakage.
"Double contingency was re-established within four hours of discovery by confirming the coolant system was drained of any possible liquid. At 1615 hours on 5-18-08 the air evacuation pumps were isolated from [DELETED] coolant system, which is the last point at which any potential liquid would have been drained from the coolant system. The condenser venting was completed at 2050 hours on 5-18-08. Coolant system leak rate completed at 2100 hours on 5-18-08 confirmed 30" vacuum and holding to show the condenser and process cooler were leak-tight."
"At 1721 hours on 5-18-08 the Plant Shift Superintendent was notified that violation of a nuclear criticality safety approval (NCSA) had occurred.
"At 1720 hours on 5-17-08, the coolant system for [DELETED] was evacuated using an R-114 evacuation pump. The recirculating cooling water (RCW) condenser for that cell had not been disconnected or vented before evacuation of coolant system vapor or air, in violation of NCSA CAS-21 Rev. 01, 'Operation and Shutdown of the Diffusion Cascade,' Control 3.2.3. That control states: 'The RCW condenser shall be disconnected or vented before coolant vapor is evacuated.'
"This control minimizes the amount of water that is available to moderate fissile material that might be present in the UF6 region of the process gas cooler.
"Coolant system leak rate testing results were logged as of 2100 hours on 5-18-08 showing the coolant system to be evacuated to 30" vacuum and holding. At that pressure the system would be below the vapor pressure of water. Therefore, the coolant system being evacuated to that level and holding would indicate that no liquid water was present in the coolant system. The system being evacuated and holding proves that not only was the condenser free of any significant RCW to coolant leaks, but the process gas cooler was also essentially leak-tight.
"The NRC Senior Resident Inspector has been notified of this event. PGDP Problem Report No. ATRC-08-1471: PGDP Event Report No. PAD-2008-18; NRC Worksheet No. 44223
"This violation represents a significant breach of NCS administrative controls for this operation: however, the safety significance of the as-found condition was quite low. The worst case enrichment [DELETED] at this location was just above the minimum fissile enrichment, so that a very large mass of optimally moderated uranium (more than [DELETED]) would have been needed for a criticality to be possible. Moderation would have required excessive water intrusion into the coolant system through condenser tube leaks, and subsequent water intrusion into the process gas region of the cooler/converter through a concurrent process gas cooler lube leak. Even though NCS Control 3.2.3 was violated, no significant water intrusion occurred. Although the as-found condition of the coolant system did not contain water, the parameter is considered lost since the typical condition of condenser tubes would be expect to result in water intrusion and would not represent a reliable barrier to in-leakage.
"Double contingency was re-established within four hours of discovery by confirming the coolant system was drained of any possible liquid. At 1615 hours on 5-18-08 the air evacuation pumps were isolated from [DELETED] coolant system, which is the last point at which any potential liquid would have been drained from the coolant system. The condenser venting was completed at 2050 hours on 5-18-08. Coolant system leak rate completed at 2100 hours on 5-18-08 confirmed 30" vacuum and holding to show the condenser and process cooler were leak-tight."