Home > NRC Library > ADAMS Public Documents

Provides proposed recommendations for resolution of issues re differing prof opinion to interpretations of App R exemption requests,formally issued in Generic Ltr 83-33.

Accession Number: ML20100E314

Date Released: Sunday, October 27, 2024

Package Contents

The following links on this page are to Adobe Portable Document Format (PDF) files. To obtain a free viewer for displaying this format, see our Plugins, Viewers, and Other Tools.

• ML20100E311 - Provides proposed recommendations for resolution of issues re differing prof opinion to interpretations of App R exemption requests,formally issued in Generic Ltr 83-33. (8 page(s), 5/2/1984)
• ML20100E337 - Discusses action plan re differing prof opinion on interpretations of App R.Steering committee & working group formed to implement review.Completion of review expected by 841026,w/formal resolution on 841231. (2 page(s), 10/4/1984)
• ML20105D035 - Forwards R Ferguson 840224 memo offering differing prof opinion from SER written by D Kubicki received in accordance w/Manual Chapter NRC-4125-035f.Comments & WV Johnston 840306 memo to RH Vollmer also encl. (1 page(s), 3/12/1984)
• ML20105C911 - Submits differing prof opinion on request for exemption from requirements of 10CFR50,App R,Section III.G.2 re fire protection of control room.Exemption would undermine NRC requirements for fire protection for safe shutdown. (2 page(s), 2/24/1984)
• ML20105C970 - Provides differing prof opinion re licensee request for exemption from Section III.G.2 of App R for control room,per 840224 comments. (3 page(s), 3/5/1984)
• ML20105D038 - Summarizes V Benaroya concerns outlined in 840224 memo re R Ferguson differing prof opinion concerning SER on Haddam Neck request for exemption from Section III.G.2 of App R for control room. (2 page(s), 3/6/1984)
• ML20100E430 - Designates recipient as responsible manager for conducting independent assessment of issues raised by RL Ferguson differing prof opinion.Response requested by 840427. (1 page(s), 3/28/1984)
• ML20100E442 - Requests 15-day extension of due date for independent assessment of issues raised by RL Ferguson differing prof opinion due to workload. (1 page(s), 4/4/1984)
• ML20100E454 - Grants 15-day extension for completion of assessment of issues raised by differing prof opinion of RL Ferguson. Written response requested by 840518. (1 page(s), 4/9/1984)
• ML20100E467 - Notifies that RL Ferguson filed differing prof opinion re util request for exemption from 10CFR50,App R requirements for fire protection of control room. (1 page(s), 4/10/1984)
• ML20100E493 - Forwards,for consideration for board notification, RL Ferguson differing prof opinion re util request for exemption from 10CFR50,App R requirements for fire protection of control room. (2 page(s), 4/9/1984)
• ML20100E522 - Responds to 840409 suggestion that board notification be considered re differing prof opinion on util SER.No notification required at present.Board notification necessary if external sources used in investigation. (1 page(s), 4/13/1984)
• ML20106A030 - Summarizes results of independent assessment of RL Ferguson 840224 differing prof opinion re staff recommendation for exemption from certain requirements of Section III.G.2 of App R to 10CFR50 for fire protection of control room. (28 page(s), 5/30/1984)
• ML20100E547 - Forwards portion of fire protection SER per control room exemption request.Issues discussed in App R debate.No basis for granting exemption.Exemption would undermine fire protection rule. (17 page(s), 3/15/1984)